Weird Reviews: As Advertised

It’s time for the next installment of our occasional series of absurd, puzzling, and/or just plain silly reviews I found online! This time, the reviews are for four different things. I share excerpts from each review (with slight edits), comment on it, and include screenshots of the original posts.

 

Eagle Falls
Photo by Google User Dmitriy Zhuravlev.

1. Cascade

Reviewed: Eagle Falls, Emerald Bay State Park, CA

“Nice views of the bay, but windy.”

Result: 5 stars for nature, despite the fact that it’s outdoors.

Eagle Falls review: "Nice views of the bay but windy"

 

service button at a Sonic in Tucson
Signage at a Sonic here in Tucson.

2. Carhops

Reviewed: Sonic Drive-In, Santa Fe, NM

“Drove in, decided on items, punched service button … No one ever came to collect money or an order.”

While it seems like 1-star service from America’s Drive-In, the review ends with a twist.

signage at a Sonic in Tucson that says "park and eat. Feel free to sit and eat awhile."

“Didn’t want to eat in my car.”

Result: So I think Sonic actually did the reviewer a favor.

Review for a Sonic Drive-In in Santa Fe. It says: "Drove in, decided on items, punched service, ready to order. Punched service a second time five minutes later and placed order. No one ever came to collect money or an order, so I left. Didn't want to eat in my car."

 

Las Vegas strip
Las Vegas during our 2016 trip.

3. Circus

Reviewed: Circus Circus Hotel and Casino parking garage in Reno, NV.

“Circus Circus Reno is a great casino and hotel, but if I were to judge it by what I saw of the parking garage, I would’ve guessed the casino was a dump, as well.”

Screenshot of small map and address from Circus Circus Parking Garage review

Strange assumption, since most venues are much less dumpy than their corresponding parking garages. But okay.

“Thank God the trash hasn’t reached the casino just yet!”

Does the reviewer think that the debris has a mind of its own? And is purposefully advancing on Circus Circus Reno?

The Blob 1958 movie poster
Via Original Vintage Movie Posters.

Result: 1 star for a parking garage looking as bad as a parking garage. Next time, I’d recommend the reviewer take the bus. And stop watching so many 1950s B-movies.

 

Review screenshot that says: “Circus Circus Reno is a great casino and hotel, but if I were to judge it by what I saw of the parking garage, I would’ve guessed the casino was a dump, as well. The smell of stale beer, trash everywhere, dirty walls in need of cleaning, and the garage elevators were not that much better. Thank God the trash hasn’t reached the casino yet!”

 

dog on a rug
Quijote, with the annoyed expression of a dog who just ran out of treats.

4. Chomp!

Reviewed: Dog treats purchased at PetSmart.

“Gave them as a treat tonight while we ate dinner. They had them gone before we even sat down…”

Sounds like the dogs loved their new treats! 5 stars?

Nope.

“…Very disappointed for the price. Wish I still had my receipt.”

Review on petsmart.com that says "What a waste of money! Bought these the other day and gave them as a treat tonight while we ate dinner. They had them gone before we even sat down. Very disappointed for the price. Wish I still had my receipt."

Result: The humans left a 1 star rating, but I’m pretty sure their canine companions would give the treats four paws up.

Mae, a German shepherd, rolls on her back playfully next to a caption that says "Meet the dogs of Amazon."
Via Amazon.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.